When Good Communication Isn’t Creating Connection

Trying harder to communicate doesn't always create more connection. According to therapist and trauma specialist Dr. Lee Long, conflict can get worse when communication becomes focused on getting another person to understand, respond differently, or change. Instead of concentrating only on what the other person is doing, Long recommends pausing to ask, “Where am I in this?” Identifying your own emotions, assumptions, patterns, and desire for control can help you respond more intentionally—even when the other person doesn't change.

Prefer to listen? Press play below.

You choose your words carefully. You try not to overreact. You explain what you mean. Maybe you have even learned how to set boundaries, name your emotions, or have a difficult conversation more productively.

And yet, sometimes the conversation still ends with two people feeling further apart.

Dr. Lee Long, a therapist, trauma specialist, and author of Wait! Where Am I in This?, believes one reason may be surprisingly easy to miss. Sometimes, while trying to communicate well, people become focused on finding the words that will produce a particular response from someone else.

“If I could just say this in such a way that makes you change,” Long explains, the focus shifts toward “how to get from you what I want” instead of understanding how we are showing up in the relationship.

That distinction matters because communication may still look thoughtful from the outside. The person may genuinely be trying to solve a problem, repair a relationship, help someone understand, or establish a boundary. But if success depends on making the other person react differently, the conversation has become attached to something neither person can actually control.

Trying to Communicate Can Become Trying to Control the Outcome

Dr. J.J. Peterson recognized this tendency in his own approach to conflict. He described wanting to figure out exactly how to say something so another person would finally understand or behave differently.

Long argues that this often creates more struggle rather than less.

The person on the other side may feel controlled or manipulated and respond by pointing back at everything you need to change. Soon, the original issue has been replaced by a fight over whose behavior is the problem.

“And none of the core stuff ever gets addressed,” Long says.

That doesn't mean people shouldn't ask for what they need. It also doesn't mean accepting behavior that makes them uncomfortable. Long uses boundaries as an example: a boundary isn't a way to make someone else stop doing something. It identifies what you will do in response.

If a family member repeatedly brings up a subject that makes you uncomfortable, for example, the response might be to say that you need to change the subject or leave the conversation. The other person still controls what they do. You control what you do next.

That distinction separates influence from control.

“I have influence sometimes, but I don't have control,” Long says.

Three Things Can Pull Your Attention Away From Yourself

Long identifies several forces that can make this harder: mind reading, the illusion of control, and our own patterns.

Mind reading happens when we fill in information we don't actually have. A short text means someone is angry. A facial expression means they disapprove. Silence means something must be wrong. Once that interpretation becomes the story we're responding to, we may be reacting to our assumption rather than what the other person has actually said.

The illusion of control works similarly. If only the right argument, tone, explanation, or boundary could guarantee the other person's response, then perhaps the situation would finally feel manageable.

But it can't.

Then there are patterns. Everyone has preferences, values, personalities, experiences, and habitual ways of responding. Those patterns aren't inherently bad, but when they remain invisible, they influence how we interpret what is happening around us.

Together, these tendencies can keep our attention almost entirely outside ourselves: What are they thinking? Why did they do that? How can I make them understand? What can I say to change this?

Long compares the alternative to using GPS. Before a navigation system can tell you how to get somewhere, it has to identify your current location.

The same is true in a difficult interaction.

“If I'm oriented and thinking that I'm somewhere that I'm not, I'm never gonna find the way to where I want to be,” he says.

“Where Am I in This?” Changes the Starting Point

The question at the center of Long's work is deceptively simple:

Where am I in this?

It turns attention away from diagnosing the other person long enough to notice what is happening internally.

Long suggests pausing and asking:

What am I thinking? What am I feeling? What am I experiencing? What am I believing?

The goal isn't endless introspection. These questions are cues designed to help someone locate themselves before deciding what to do next.

That can be more difficult than it sounds, particularly when anxiety is involved.

Peterson described a professional relationship in which interactions with another person began triggering significant anxiety and panic. At first, he could identify the anxiety, but when someone asked what he was actually feeling underneath it, he couldn't name it.

Long says that experience isn't unusual. By the time someone reaches panic, he explains, the system is “redlining,” making it difficult to identify much of anything.

He also sees another problem: “We're really more focused on what's going on out there than what's going on in here inside of us.”

In one example, a client struggling to identify what was underneath his anger used a feelings wheel until one word finally fit: disrespected. Naming it didn't automatically solve the situation, but it gave him information he hadn't had before.

Emotions Are Information, Not Instructions

Long compares emotions to the dashboard of a car.

When the check-engine light appears, it doesn't necessarily mean the engine is about to seize. It means something needs attention.

“Emotions are a lot like that if we can pay attention to them,” he says.

That changes the role emotions can play in conflict. Anxiety doesn't automatically mean another person is dangerous. Anger doesn't automatically prove someone else is wrong. Fear doesn't automatically dictate what should happen next.

But those emotions can tell us that something is happening inside us that deserves attention.

Once we know more about that, we have more choices about how to respond.

That might mean asking a question instead of assuming we know what someone thinks. It might mean expressing hurt underneath anger. It could mean setting a boundary, leaving a conversation, asking for something different, or simply recognizing that another person's beliefs and behavior are theirs to own.

The point isn't to eliminate conflict. It's to know where you are before deciding where to go.

Connection Doesn't Require Controlling the Other Person

This is where Long's argument circles back to the larger problem of disconnection.

When Peterson asks whether our attempts to change one another might be contributing to broader feelings of disconnection and disengagement, Long answers strongly: “Frankly, I think it is the core reason why we are in this place, why our world remains so divided.”

His alternative isn't agreement.

It is the ability to stay aware of what another person's words bring up in us without immediately making changing that person the goal.

That applies in families, friendships, workplaces, leadership, and conversations between people who see the world very differently. Two people may still disagree. Someone may still need to say no. A boundary may still be necessary. A relationship may still be difficult.

Coming back to yourself doesn't guarantee the outcome.

It gives you a clearer place from which to choose your response.

And perhaps that's the paradox at the center of better communication: connection doesn't always begin with figuring out the perfect thing to say to someone else.

Sometimes it begins by asking, “Where am I in this?”

Previous
Previous

Some Answers Only Come After You Start

Next
Next

Let AI Make Room for What Only You Can Do